CL-CRI-1171 Pay-Per-Install Network Analysis

Cybercrime Group Uses YouTube Gaming Lures in Massive PPI Scheme

HIGH
September 9, 2026
18m read
Threat ActorMalwareCyberattack

Related Entities

Threat Actors

CL-CRI-1171

Products & Tech

WinDirStat

Other

YouTubeInsomnia RATARKTunnelDocro HijackerGCleanerSocks5Systemz

Full Report

Executive Summary

A recent investigation by Palo Alto Networks' Unit 42 has exposed a long-running and extensive cybercrime operation tracked as CL-CRI-1171. This threat cluster operates a sophisticated pay-per-install (PPI) service, leveraging popular platforms like YouTube and search engine optimization (SEO) poisoning to achieve widespread infections. The campaign has been active for at least two years, successfully compromising both individual gamers and high-value targets within corporate, government, and critical infrastructure sectors.

The operation's effectiveness stems from its use of a generic, custom-built loader that appears as unremarkable commodity malware, thus avoiding deeper security analysis. This loader serves as a delivery mechanism for a rotating bundle of payloads from various cybercriminal clients. Analysis revealed the distribution of several malware families, including the newly identified Insomnia RAT and the previously undocumented ARKTunnel and Docro Hijacker malware. The infrastructure supporting this campaign is vast, involving over 10,000 loader samples and more than 200 rotational command-and-control (C2) domains, highlighting the scale and persistence of this threat.

Threat Overview

The CL-CRI-1171 operation functions as a Malware-as-a-Service (MaaS) platform, specifically a PPI network. The operators provide an infection service to other threat actors, who pay to have their own malicious payloads distributed to a wide audience. The investigation was triggered by two seemingly routine infections at separate organizations that shared an identical, untracked loader, which led to the discovery of the broader campaign.

Key components of the threat include:

  • Infection Vectors: The group employs a two-pronged approach to lure victims:

    1. YouTube Gaming Lures: The threat actors managed at least eleven popular YouTube channels with hundreds of thousands of followers. These channels offered legitimate-seeming gaming content, such as tutorials on improving game performance, while tricking viewers into downloading malicious tools from linked sites.
    2. SEO Poisoning: This funnel targeted a more professional audience by promoting trojanized versions of legitimate software, such as a Bluetooth driver and the popular utility WinDirStat. Users searching for this software would be directed to malicious sites, leading to malware deployment on corporate endpoints.
  • Payload Delivery: A single, custom loader is used across all infection vectors. This loader is designed to be disposable and is capable of fetching and executing multiple, unrelated malware payloads on a compromised system. This means a single infection can result in the deployment of a backdoor, a data hijacker, and other threats simultaneously, each with its own objectives and C2 infrastructure.

Technical Analysis

The core of the CL-CRI-1171 operation is its shared infrastructure, which allows it to scale effectively while remaining difficult to track.

Loader and C2 Infrastructure

The primary common denominator is a custom loader, with over 10,000 unique samples identified. This loader is responsible for the initial compromise and subsequent download of additional payloads. It communicates with a sprawling C2 network characterized by:

  • Rotational Domains: Over 200 unique hostnames were observed.
  • Naming Pattern: Domains follow a distinctive two-word compound naming pattern (e.g., bubbleslip, churchpail, dinosaursjam).
  • TLDs: The domains rotate across .xyz, .cfd, .space, and .info top-level domains.

This rotational infrastructure makes blocklisting based on individual domains ineffective.

Malware Payloads

The PPI model allows for a flexible and rotating set of payloads. While the investigation identified a core bundle in rotation from July 2025 to April 2026, other malware families were also observed. The analyzed payloads include:

  • Insomnia RAT: A previously unnamed remote access trojan (RAT) given its name by Unit 42. RATs provide attackers with persistent remote control over a compromised system.
  • ARKTunnel: A previously unreported malware family, likely used for creating covert communication channels or tunneling traffic.
  • Docro Hijacker: Another previously unreported malware, suggesting it is custom-developed for or by this group. Its function is likely related to browser or data hijacking.
  • Other Payloads: In a separate infection in June 2026, the same loader delivered GCleaner and Socks5Systemz, demonstrating the modular nature of the PPI service.

MITRE ATT&CK TTPs

The tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) observed or inferred in this campaign include:

Tactic
Initial Access
Technique ID
Name
Spearphishing Attachment
Description
The use of YouTube videos with malicious links serves as a form of social engineering to entice users to download a malicious file.
Tactic
Initial Access
Technique ID
Name
Malicious File
Description
SEO poisoning techniques lead users to download trojanized versions of legitimate software.
Tactic
Execution
Technique ID
Name
User Execution: Malicious File
Description
The entire infection chain relies on the user executing the downloaded malicious loader.
Tactic
Defense Evasion
Technique ID
Name
Obfuscated Files or Information
Description
The loader is described as generic and untracked, a form of camouflage to appear as low-risk adware and evade deeper scrutiny.
Tactic
Command and Control
Technique ID
Name
Application Layer Protocol: Web Protocols
Description
The loader communicates with C2 servers over standard web protocols (HTTP/HTTPS) to download payloads.
Tactic
Command and Control
Technique ID
Name
Ingress Tool Transfer
Description
The primary function of the loader is to download and install subsequent malware payloads onto the victim's machine.

Impact Assessment

The CL-CRI-1171 campaign poses a significant risk due to its broad targeting and deceptive nature. The impact extends beyond the initial infection:

  • Enterprise Risk: By successfully penetrating corporate, government, and critical infrastructure networks, the operation provides a foothold for more severe attacks. A seemingly minor adware infection could conceal a RAT, leading to data exfiltration, corporate espionage, or a ransomware deployment.
  • Multi-Threat Deployment: The PPI model means a single compromised endpoint can be sold to multiple 'customers'. This results in layered threats, complicating incident response and remediation. An organization might clean one payload while remaining unaware of others operating on the same machine.
  • Evasion and Persistence: The use of a generic loader that is dismissed as commodity adware is a key element of the campaign's success. This allows the threats to persist on networks for extended periods, as they are not flagged for priority investigation.
  • Supply Chain Risk: The trojanizing of legitimate software tools like WinDirStat represents a form of software supply chain risk, where users' trust in known tools is exploited.

IOCs — Directly from Articles

No specific file hashes, IP addresses, or domains were provided in the source article. However, the report describes the C2 domain structure.

Type
Domain Pattern
Value
[two-word-compound]
Description
C2 domains follow a pattern of two concatenated English words, such as bubbleslip or dinosaursjam.
Type
TLD
Value
.xyz, .cfd, .space, .info
Description
The C2 domains were observed rotating across these four top-level domains.

Cyber Observables — Hunting Hints

Security teams can hunt for potentially related activity using the following patterns:

Type
url_pattern
Value
links from YouTube descriptions
Description
Malicious download links promoted in the descriptions of gaming-related videos.
Context
Web proxy logs, DNS logs
Confidence
medium
Type
file_name
Value
WinDirStat_setup.exe, bluetooth_driver_installer.exe
Description
Trojanized installers for legitimate software downloaded from non-official sources.
Context
EDR telemetry, file system monitoring
Confidence
high
Type
domain
Value
(word1)(word2).xyz
Description
DNS queries for domains matching the two-word compound pattern on suspicious TLDs.
Context
DNS query logs, SIEM
Confidence
high
Type
domain
Value
(word1)(word2).cfd
Description
DNS queries for domains matching the two-word compound pattern on suspicious TLDs.
Context
DNS query logs, SIEM
Confidence
high
Type
network_traffic_pattern
Value
HTTP/S POST to *.xyz
Description
Outbound traffic from endpoints to domains on suspicious TLDs, especially from processes spawned by recently downloaded files.
Context
Netflow, Firewall logs, EDR
Confidence
medium

Detection & Response

Detecting and responding to this threat requires looking beyond surface-level indicators.

Detection

  1. Enhanced Scrutiny: Do not dismiss generic or untracked malware alerts as low-priority. Any loader activity should be investigated for subsequent payload downloads.
  2. Network Monitoring: Implement rules to detect and alert on connections to the suspicious TLDs (.xyz, .cfd, .space, .info), especially when combined with unusual domain name patterns. Use Network Traffic Analysis to baseline normal activity and spot anomalies.
  3. EDR Queries: Use Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) tools to hunt for process chains where a browser or downloaded application spawns unusual child processes or makes network connections to rotational domains.
  4. File Analysis: Use File Analysis to inspect downloaded executables, particularly those for popular utilities sourced from outside official repositories.

Response

  • Isolation: If an endpoint is found to be infected with the loader, immediately isolate it from the network to prevent further payload downloads or lateral movement.
  • Full Forensics: Perform a full forensic analysis on the isolated machine. Do not assume the initial detected malware is the only threat. Actively search for evidence of other payloads (e.g., RATs, info-stealers, proxy tools).
  • Credential Reset: Assume all credentials stored on or used from the compromised machine are compromised. Initiate a full password reset for the affected user and any service accounts.

Mitigation

Defending against this multi-faceted threat requires a layered security approach.

  1. User Training: Conduct security awareness training focused on the dangers of downloading software from unvetted sources. Emphasize the risks of SEO poisoning and lures on social media platforms like YouTube.
  2. Application Control: Implement application whitelisting or strict software policies that prevent users from installing unauthorized software. This is a key control against executing trojanized installers. This corresponds to MITRE's Execution Prevention mitigation.
  3. Web Filtering: Configure web filters to block access to known malicious websites and consider restricting access to newly registered domains or less reputable TLDs like .xyz and .cfd for high-risk user groups.
  4. Endpoint Protection: Ensure endpoint protection platforms (EPP/EDR) are configured to scan all downloaded files and monitor for suspicious process behavior, such as a utility installer attempting to make outbound C2 connections.
  5. Network Segmentation: Segment networks to limit the ability of a compromised endpoint to communicate with critical assets. This can contain the impact of a successful infection by a RAT or other payload.

Timeline of Events

1
September 1, 2024
CL-CRI-1171 cybercrime operation is estimated to have begun, operating for at least two years prior to the report.
2
July 1, 2025
The payload rotation including Insomnia RAT, ARKTunnel, and Docro Hijacker was observed to be active.
3
April 15, 2026
Unit 42 investigates two separate incidents involving the same loader, which delivered Insomnia RAT, ARKTunnel, and Docro Hijacker.
4
June 1, 2026
A subsequent infection was observed where the loader delivered two different payloads: GCleaner and Socks5Systemz.
5
September 9, 2026
This article was published
6
September 9, 2026
Unit 42 publishes its research on the CL-CRI-1171 pay-per-install network.

MITRE ATT&CK Mitigations

Train users to recognize and avoid social engineering tactics like those used on YouTube and through SEO poisoning, and to only download software from official sources.

Filter and monitor outbound network traffic to block connections to known malicious domains and suspicious TLDs (.xyz, .cfd, etc.) used by the C2 infrastructure.

Use web filtering and URL analysis to block users from accessing malicious links and downloading files from untrusted sources.

Mapped D3FEND Techniques:

Implement application control policies, such as executable allowlisting, to prevent the execution of unauthorized and potentially trojanized software.

Mapped D3FEND Techniques:

Deploy and maintain endpoint protection solutions to detect and quarantine the loader and its subsequent payloads based on signatures and behavioral analysis.

Mapped D3FEND Techniques:

Audit

M1047enterprise

Enable comprehensive logging of process execution, DNS queries, and network traffic to support threat hunting and incident investigation.

Mapped D3FEND Techniques:

D3FEND Defensive Countermeasures

To counter the CL-CRI-1171 threat, organizations should implement robust Network Traffic Analysis (NTA). This involves deploying sensors at key network egress points to monitor all outbound traffic. The primary goal is to detect the loader's C2 communications. Configure NTA tools and SIEM to specifically alert on DNS queries and HTTP/S connections to the TLDs favored by this group: .xyz, .cfd, .space, and .info. Create rules that correlate this with domain names that fit the two-word compound pattern observed in the campaign. Establish a baseline of normal outbound traffic for workstations and servers. An alert should be triggered when a user workstation, after downloading a new executable, initiates connections to a newly observed domain on one of these TLDs. This technique is critical for detecting active infections that have bypassed endpoint controls, providing a chance to intervene before secondary payloads like Insomnia RAT can be downloaded and activated.

Executable Allowlisting is a highly effective countermeasure against the CL-CRI-1171's infection vectors. Since the attack relies on tricking users into running a trojanized executable (e.g., a fake WinDirStat installer), a properly configured allowlisting policy would prevent the malicious file from running in the first place. Organizations should deploy solutions like Windows Defender Application Control or AppLocker. Start by running in audit mode on a representative group of systems to build a baseline of legitimate applications and installers. Once the baseline is established, switch to enforcement mode. For developer or IT administrator machines that require more flexibility, use a managed installer model where all new software must be deployed through a trusted, centralized software management system. This directly mitigates the risk from both the SEO poisoning and YouTube lure vectors by ensuring only vetted and approved executables can run, regardless of how they arrive on the endpoint.

Leveraging Process Analysis via an EDR solution is crucial for detecting the post-execution behavior of the CL-CRI-1171 loader. Even if the initial binary is not detected by signature, its actions can betray its malicious nature. Security teams should configure EDR policies to monitor for suspicious process parent-child relationships. For example, an alert should be generated if a process associated with a web browser (chrome.exe, firefox.exe) spawns a downloaded executable that in turn spawns a command shell (cmd.exe) or PowerShell (powershell.exe) to make outbound network connections. Specifically for this threat, create detection rules that look for any process making network connections to the suspicious TLDs (.xyz, .cfd, etc.). This behavioral approach is resilient to the threat actor's use of over 10,000 unique loader samples, as the fundamental behavior of 'download and execute' remains consistent. This allows for detection even when the specific file hash is unknown.

Timeline of Events

1
September 1, 2024

CL-CRI-1171 cybercrime operation is estimated to have begun, operating for at least two years prior to the report.

2
July 1, 2025

The payload rotation including Insomnia RAT, ARKTunnel, and Docro Hijacker was observed to be active.

3
April 15, 2026

Unit 42 investigates two separate incidents involving the same loader, which delivered Insomnia RAT, ARKTunnel, and Docro Hijacker.

4
June 1, 2026

A subsequent infection was observed where the loader delivered two different payloads: GCleaner and Socks5Systemz.

5
September 9, 2026

Unit 42 publishes its research on the CL-CRI-1171 pay-per-install network.

Sources & References

Untracked Nightmares: The Threats Hiding Behind Commodity Infrastructure
Unit 42 (unit42.paloaltonetworks.com) September 8, 2026

Article Author

Jason Gomes

Jason Gomes

• Cybersecurity Practitioner

Cybersecurity professional with over 10 years of specialized experience in security operations, threat intelligence, incident response, and security automation. Expertise spans SOAR/XSOAR orchestration, threat intelligence platforms, SIEM/UEBA analytics, and building cyber fusion centers. Background includes technical enablement, solution architecture for enterprise and government clients, and implementing security automation workflows across IR, TIP, and SOC use cases.

Threat Intelligence & AnalysisSecurity Orchestration (SOAR/XSOAR)Incident Response & Digital ForensicsSecurity Operations Center (SOC)SIEM & Security AnalyticsCyber Fusion & Threat SharingSecurity Automation & IntegrationManaged Detection & Response (MDR)

Editorial Standards & Analyst Review

CyberNetSec.io uses automation to assist source monitoring, deduplication, observable extraction, and structured intelligence generation. Published analysis follows human-defined editorial standards and adds defensive context including MITRE ATT&CK, D3FEND, STIX, and Sigma where applicable. Read our editorial policy.

Tags

PPIPay-Per-InstallSEO PoisoningYouTubeMalware LoaderInsomnia RATARKTunnelDocro HijackerCybercrimeCL-CRI-1171

📢 Share This Article

Help others stay informed about cybersecurity threats

🎯 MITRE ATT&CK Mapped

Every tactic, technique, and sub-technique used in this threat has been identified and mapped to the MITRE ATT&CK framework for consistent, actionable threat language.

🧠 Enriched & Analyzed

Observables and indicators of compromise (IOCs) have been extracted and cataloged. Risk has been assessed and correlated with known threat actors and historical campaigns.

🛡️ Actionable Guidance

Detection rules, incident response steps, and D3FEND-aligned mitigation strategies are included so your team can act on this intelligence immediately.

🔗 STIX Visualizer

Structured threat data is packaged as a STIX 2.1 bundle and can be visualized as an interactive graph — relationships between actors, malware, techniques, and indicators.

Sigma Generator

Sigma detection rules are derived from the threat techniques in this article and can be converted for deployment across any major SIEM or EDR platform.